Are Cheat Days OK

Strict diets may promise quick results, but they often come with a side of guilt, burnout, and cravings. Enter the cheat day: one glorious, anything-goes day that many use as a mental and physical reset. But are these breaks in your diet plan helpful or harmful?

Let’s explore what the science says about cheat meals, their impact on metabolism and psychology, and whether “cheating” might actually help you stick with your goals.

What Is a Cheat Day, Exactly?

Cheat days mean different things to different people, but most definitions fall into three camps:

• Timed indulgence: Eating anything you want for a set time period, like one meal or a full day.

• Intentional deviations: Occasionally enjoying foods that are normally avoided on your diet.

• Mindful flexibility: Letting go of food rules entirely and practicing intuitive eating.

No matter the form, cheat days create space for satisfaction and flexibility in a healthy eating plan when done intentionally.

How Cheat Days Affect the Body

Cheat days are often praised for giving your metabolism a temporary boost, mostly by impacting leptin a hormone that tells your brain when to stop eating. Calorie restriction can lower leptin levels, potentially slowing metabolism and increasing hunger. Some research has found:

• Leptin levels may increase by 30% for up to 24 hours after a calorie-rich meal.

• Overeating boosts metabolism by 3% to 10% temporarily, but the effect is short-lived.

A 2018 study on intermittent dieting found that people who took diet breaks lost more weight and regained less than those who followed a strict plan without pauses. But moderation matters: A 2017 study on rats showed that frequent cheat meals (three times a week) can negatively impact gut bacteria similar to eating junk food all the time.

If you’re managing chronic conditions like diabetes, high cholesterol, or hypertension, it’s crucial to plan cheat meals carefully. And for keto dieters, even one cheat meal high in simple carbs may spike blood sugar and temporarily damage blood vessels, according to 2019 findings.

Cheat Day Psychology: Reward or Risk?

The emotional side of cheat meals is just as important. Some studies suggest cheat days can:

• Increase motivation by reducing feelings of deprivation.

• Help people stick to a plan long term.

• Support healthier relationships with food if approached without guilt.

A 2016 study found that dieters who indulged occasionally felt more motivated and in control. But it’s not a license to binge. Instead of labeling foods as “good” or “bad,” try seeing cheat meals as a celebration an idea backed by a 2014 study showing that people who viewed cake as celebratory (vs. guilt-inducing) were more successful in losing weight.

Still, there’s a downside to cheat-day thinking. Saving up for a “binge day” can lead to an all-or-nothing mentality that encourages overeating and psychological distress. A 2018 study linked the concept of cheat meals with behaviors seen in binge eating episodes, suggesting this pattern may trigger disordered eating for some people.

From Cheat to Treat: A Mindful Reframe

If you're craving balance, intuitive eating might be the better path. This approach emphasizes:

• Eating when you're hungry (not because it’s a “cheat day”).

• Choosing foods you enjoy.

• Honoring fullness and satisfaction.

• Letting go of guilt around food.

Mindfulness around eating has been shown to reduce binge behaviors and help with weight regulation. A 2017 review confirmed that mindfulness-based eating habits can prevent weight gain and support overall well-being.

Tips for a Healthy Cheat Day (or Meal)

If you choose to include cheat meals in your routine, keep these tips in mind:

• Plan ahead: Know what you’ll eat and how much to avoid impulsive decisions.

• Savor it: Eat slowly and enjoy every bite.

• Keep balance in mind: Try to include some fiber or protein to reduce sugar spikes.

• Don’t beat yourself up: One meal won’t undo your progress, and guilt often does more harm than the food itself.

The Takeaway

Cheat days can offer physical and psychological benefits if you approach them with balance and mindfulness. Occasional indulgences may increase leptin, rev up your metabolism, and help you feel more satisfied with your overall eating plan.

That said, mindset matters. Viewing a cheat meal as a treat not a failure can help you maintain a healthy relationship with food and stay committed to your long-term goals.

So if your week of kale and grilled chicken ends with a slice of pizza and a scoop of gelato, enjoy it. Just remember: you're not cheating you’re living.

If this article helped shift your perspective, share it with someone or subscribe to our newsletter for more.