How to Break Free from the ‘Thinner Is Better’ Mentality

“You can never be too rich or too thin.”

It’s a phrase that has circulated for decades, reinforcing a cultural ideal that thinness equals success, beauty, and health. Even as body positivity gains momentum, many of us still struggle with internalized beliefs that being thinner is inherently better.

If you’ve ever thought, That’s great for them, but I still need to be thin, you’re not alone. These beliefs are deeply ingrained, and breaking free from them takes conscious effort. Here’s why we’re still trapped in the thin-is-better mindset and how to start letting it go.

Why Do We Believe Thin Is Better?

1. We’ve Been Told Thinness Equals Health

From a young age, we’re taught that weight and health are directly linked. Medical professionals often emphasize BMI as a key indicator of health, despite growing evidence that weight alone doesn’t determine overall well-being.

For example, a 2016 study in Obesity found that nearly half of people categorized as "overweight" and a third of those labeled "obese" were actually metabolically healthy. Meanwhile, some people in the "normal" BMI range had health issues like high cholesterol or high blood pressure.

Despite this, the medical industry has gone to extreme lengths to “solve” weight-related health concerns. From jaw wiring in the 1970s to gastric surgeries and off-label use of weight-loss medications today, society continues to reinforce the idea that thinness is a medical goal rather than just a body type.

2. Society Equates Thinness with Beauty

Studies show that body image concerns start alarmingly early. Research by the Professional Association for Childcare and Early Years (PACEY) found that children as young as 3 years old express dissatisfaction with their bodies.

“Babies aren’t born with body image thoughts,” says Melissa Streno, PsyD, a psychologist specializing in body image and disordered eating. “But from a very young age, we absorb messages about which bodies are valued.”

And those messages are everywhere. Social media, advertising, movies, and even family conversations reinforce the idea that thinness is the standard of beauty. A single minute of exposure to a thinner-than-average model can shift our perception of attractiveness, according to research in Body of Truth.

How to Break Free from the Thin Ideal

Shifting your mindset takes time, patience, and intentional work. Here are five strategies to help challenge and unlearn the belief that thinner is better.

1. Assess Your Thoughts About Thinness

Start by asking yourself:

• Do I restrict food or punish myself for eating?

• Do I measure my worth based on my weight or clothing size?

• Do I avoid activities, events, or social situations because of my body image?

Writing down your thoughts can help you identify patterns and triggers that reinforce the thin ideal. Once you recognize them, you can start challenging those beliefs.

2. Define What Thin Means to You

Consider where your beliefs about thinness come from. Is it from family expectations? Media influence? A past experience?

“We internalize messages that being thin means being successful, attractive, or worthy,” says Stephanie Roth-Goldberg, LCSW-R, CEDS, a licensed clinical social worker. “But when you really examine those beliefs, you can start to dismantle them.”

Try journaling about what thinness represents to you and whether those beliefs actually align with your values.

3. Shift the Focus to What Your Body Can Do

Instead of focusing on how your body looks, appreciate what it does for you.

• Can you hug loved ones?

• Can you dance, stretch, or move in ways that bring you joy?

• Can you go for a walk and enjoy fresh air?

Streno often asks her clients to list five things they appreciate about their body that have nothing to do with appearance. This simple exercise helps reframe self-worth beyond physical size.

4. Recognize and Challenge Negative Thoughts

When a critical thought pops up like I need to lose weight to be attractive pause and question it.

• Who told me this?

• Is this belief serving me, or is it making me feel worse?

• What would I say to a friend who had this thought about themselves?

Over time, challenging these thoughts helps weaken their grip and creates space for a more neutral or positive view of your body.

5. Imagine Life Without the Pursuit of Thinness

Think about how much time, energy, and stress go into dieting, body-checking, or worrying about weight.

Now imagine: What could you do with that energy instead?

• Enjoy meals without guilt?

• Pursue hobbies or passions without body-related worries?

• Feel more present and engaged in your daily life?

“The most difficult part of recovery is self-acceptance,” Streno says. “But on the other side is freedom from obsessive thoughts about food, weight, and body image.”

The Bottom Line

Breaking free from the thinner-is-better mentality isn’t easy, but it’s possible. By challenging societal norms, questioning your beliefs, and appreciating your body for more than its size, you can take steps toward a healthier relationship with yourself.

If you found this article helpful, share it with a friend or subscribe to our newsletter for more expert insights.