The Real Reasons Your Bunions Keep Coming Back

Bunions those painful, bony bumps near the base of your big toe can be frustratingly persistent. Even after finding temporary relief, many people find that bunion pain keeps coming back. Why? Because the root causes of bunions often go beyond footwear and unless those underlying factors are addressed, symptoms are likely to return.

If you’re tired of recurring bunion flares, here’s what you need to know about what causes them, why they return, and what you can do to feel better long term.

What Exactly Is a Bunion?

A bunion, or hallux valgus, forms when pressure on the big toe causes it to shift toward the other toes, pushing the joint at its base outward. Over time, this pressure creates a visible bump on the side of your foot that can become red, swollen, and painful especially when walking or wearing certain shoes.

Symptoms of a bunion may include:

• A visible bump on the side of the big toe

• Pain or soreness, especially when walking

• Numbness or tingling in the toe

• Swelling and redness

• Corns or calluses from friction

• Stiffness or limited movement in the big toe

Why Do Bunions Keep Coming Back?

Bunions are progressive, meaning they often get worse over time. Even if symptoms improve temporarily, the underlying joint misalignment may still be present. Factors that make bunions return or worsen include:

• Tight or narrow shoes, especially those with pointed toes or high heels

• Flat feet or other foot structure problems

• Inherited foot anatomy up to 70% of bunion cases have a family history

• Inflammatory conditions, like rheumatoid arthritis

• Pregnancy, which can loosen foot ligaments and flatten the arches

• Foot injuries or joint instability

• Aging, as natural wear and tear and joint changes increase with time

Even well-meaning changes, like switching shoes, may not fully stop bunion progression if other risk factors aren’t addressed.

What Makes Bunion Flares Worse?

Sudden bunion flares often feel like a sharp increase in pain, swelling, or difficulty walking. Common triggers include:

• Wearing heels or shoes with a narrow toe box

• Walking or standing for long periods, especially on hard surfaces

• Strenuous foot activities like running, hiking, or sports

• Weather changes that may cause joint inflammation

How to Manage and Prevent Bunion Pain

While bunions can’t be reversed without surgery, you can often manage and reduce symptoms with at-home strategies and professional support.

Daily relief tips:

• Apply ice packs to reduce inflammation

• Take NSAIDs (like ibuprofen) for pain and swelling

• Wear gel bunion pads inside shoes to cushion the joint

• Use toe splints or taping at night to reduce pressure

• Choose wide, supportive shoes with a roomy toe box

• Walk barefoot when possible (on safe, flat surfaces)

• Use custom orthotics or inserts to support arch alignment

Lifestyle habits that help:

• Stretch your calves to reduce pressure on the forefoot

• Strengthen your feet with toe mobility and foot exercises

• Maintain a healthy weight to reduce stress on the joints

• Avoid footwear that forces the toes into unnatural positions

When to See a Podiatrist

If your bunions are interfering with daily life or not responding to conservative care, it’s time to consult a podiatrist. These foot and ankle specialists can assess your specific foot structure and recommend advanced options, such as:

• Custom orthotics for better foot alignment

• Dry needling, which may help reduce pain and improve joint mobility by targeting trigger points and inflammation

• Physical therapy to improve range of motion

• Corticosteroid injections for short-term pain relief

When Is Bunion Surgery an Option?

Surgery may be recommended if:

• Pain is severe and constant

• Walking becomes difficult

• Non-surgical treatments are no longer effective

• The bunion is visibly progressing

Surgical options vary based on the size and severity of the bunion. Most are same-day procedures, and recovery may involve a few weeks of limited weight-bearing.

Bunions and Gender: Why Women Are Affected More

Bunions are more common in women, especially those over age 60. Shoe design plays a major role many women’s shoes have narrower toe boxes and less arch support. Additionally, hormonal changes during pregnancy can affect ligament flexibility, increasing the risk for developing bunions or making existing ones worse.

The Bottom Line

Bunions don’t usually go away on their own but they don’t always require surgery, either. By focusing on foot-friendly shoes, supportive care, and targeted relief strategies, you can significantly reduce bunion pain and prevent flares.

If you’ve tried managing your bunions and they keep coming back, it may be time for a more personalized plan. A podiatrist can help uncover the root cause and guide you toward lasting relief.

Like content that helps you move through life more comfortably? Subscribe to our newsletter or share this with a friend dealing with foot pain.