Are Eye Creams Really Necessary or Can Your Face Lotion Do the Job?

When it comes to skincare, there’s no shortage of products to choose from and one of the most debated is eye cream. Do you really need it, or can your regular face lotion work just as well for the delicate under-eye area? To settle this skincare conundrum, we asked board-certified dermatologists to share their insights.

Do Eye Creams Actually Work?

The short answer: Yes, they can work but whether you need one depends on your skin concerns.

“Eye creams with clinically proven ingredients can provide visible benefits,” says Blair Murphy-Rose, MD, a dermatologist based in New York City. These targeted formulas are designed to address specific issues like puffiness, dark circles, and fine lines. While the effects may not be dramatic, they can be noticeable over time with consistent use.

Key active ingredients to look for:

• Caffeine and witch hazel for puffiness.

• Vitamin C, retinol, and licorice extract for dark circles.

• Hyaluronic acid and retinol for smoothing fine lines.

Eye creams are especially helpful for people with visible under-eye concerns. For those without major issues, extending your regular skincare routine to the under-eye area may suffice.

How Are Eye Creams Different From Face Lotion?

While face lotions and eye creams share some ingredients, their formulations differ in important ways.

“The skin around the eyes is thinner, drier, and more delicate than the rest of the face,” explains Stacey Tull, MD, a board-certified dermatologist. Eye creams are often more moisturizing and contain lower concentrations of active ingredients to reduce irritation.

Unlike face moisturizers, which are primarily designed to hydrate and seal in other products, eye creams target specific concerns like dark circles, puffiness, and wrinkles. They’re also less likely to cause breakouts since the under-eye area isn’t prone to acne.

Can You Use Face Lotion Around Your Eyes?

In some cases, yes. If your face moisturizer contains gentle, effective ingredients like hyaluronic acid or vitamin C, you may be able to apply it around your eyes. However, Dr. Tull advises caution: “Test the product on a small area to ensure it doesn’t irritate the sensitive under-eye skin.”

That said, for more advanced concerns like pronounced wrinkles or puffiness, eye creams formulated with targeted actives may be more effective.

Alternatives to Eye Cream

If you’re not ready to invest in an eye cream, there are other ways to care for the skin around your eyes:

Lifestyle Adjustments

• Wear sunscreen and sunglasses to protect the delicate skin around your eyes from sun damage.

• Get 7–9 hours of sleep each night to reduce puffiness and dark circles.

• Stay hydrated and limit sodium to minimize fluid retention under your eyes.

Home Remedies

• Apply a cool compress or chilled green tea bags to reduce puffiness.

• Prop your head up with an extra pillow to prevent fluid buildup while you sleep.

Professional Treatments

• Laser treatments can improve skin elasticity and reduce wrinkles.

• Chemical peels can brighten dark under-eye areas.

• Hyaluronic acid fillers can address hollowness and shadowing.

The Bottom Line

While not everyone needs an eye cream, they are beneficial for addressing specific under-eye concerns like puffiness, dark circles, or fine lines. Eye creams are formulated to be gentle on the delicate skin around your eyes and may provide results that regular face lotions can’t.

If you already use a retinol or vitamin C serum, check if it’s safe for the under-eye area you might not need a separate product. Ultimately, the decision comes down to your personal skincare goals and whether you feel an eye cream is worth the extra step in your routine.

Share this article or subscribe to our newsletter for more skincare tips.