Not automatically. Cleveland Clinic says many sourdough loaves use the same all-purpose flour as ordinary white bread, so the name alone does not tell you how much fiber you are getting.
Cleveland Clinic registered dietitian Beth Czerwony explains that a lot of sourdough recipes call for all-purpose flour, the same flour in your average white bread. During manufacturing, all-purpose and other white refined flours lose much of their fiber. Fiber matters because it helps you stay fuller longer and keeps your body from fully absorbing carbohydrates, which means a smaller effect on your blood sugar.
Consumer Reports makes the same point with numbers: a 1-ounce slice of sourdough white bread contains 1 gram of fiber, and so does a 1-ounce slice of plain white bread. For more fiber, Cleveland Clinic suggests recipes and bakery loaves made with whole-wheat, spelt or rye flour instead of all-purpose flour, since those flours keep more fiber when milled. Read the ingredients list rather than trusting the word sourdough on the bag.
Fermentation does bring something. Czerwony says it creates prebiotics, which feed the healthy bacteria in your gut, and it eats up some of the natural sugars in the grain. The clinic says that gives sourdough a lower glycemic index than some other breads, around 55 compared with 100 for a typical slice of white bread. Still, Czerwony would not tell someone with diabetes to switch to eating only sourdough. It can fit into an overall healthy diet if you like it.
One more thing the name does not promise: sourdough is not gluten-free. Fermentation lowers the gluten in the bread, but Cleveland Clinic says people with celiac disease who have to avoid all gluten are likely to be advised against it.
Consumer Reports explains that sourdough starts with a starter, a mix of flour and water left to ferment for several days. Wild yeasts and bacteria in the flour and the air feed on it, and the mixture bubbles and grows before it goes into the dough. The longer the fermentation, the stronger the sour taste, according to Willow Jarosh, a culinary registered dietitian in New York City. Cleveland Clinic notes that most bread relies on added yeast, and some sourdough recipes add yeast too, to speed things along.
Not every loaf labeled sourdough is made the slow way. Consumer Reports suggests checking the ingredients list for sourdough culture or starter and no yeast, or asking the bakery whether the bread is slowly leavened for at least 8 to 24 hours. One thing fermentation does not deliver is probiotics. Jarosh says the bacteria in sourdough are killed during baking, so unlike yogurt or kimchi it does not add live healthy bacteria to your system.
Consumer Reports does report two other possible upsides. The microbes in sourdough break down phytic acid, a compound in some flours that binds minerals such as zinc, iron and calcium, which may improve the nutritional quality of the bread. And registered dietitian Kate Scarlata, who specializes in digestive health, says ordinary wheat bread leavened with baker's yeast is high in fructans, a trigger for many people with irritable bowel syndrome, so sourdough may be easier on their stomachs. Czerwony keeps it all in perspective. Sourdough can be part of a healthy diet, she says, but it would not be her first go-to for someone looking to eat better.
Talk to your doctor if bread repeatedly causes digestive symptoms or if you are managing diabetes and wondering where sourdough fits.
