Reusing Plastic Water Bottles Can Do More Harm Than You Think

Grabbing a plastic water bottle on the go and refilling it later might seem like a smart way to stay hydrated and reduce waste. But before you make that a daily habit, it’s worth knowing what really happens when you reuse a disposable water bottle.

From bacterial buildup to chemical leaching and long-term environmental harm, reusing that bottle may be riskier than you think.

Not All Plastics Are Created Equal

Most single-use water bottles are made from polyethylene terephthalate (PET), a lightweight plastic marked with the recycling code “1.” PET is designed for one-time use, not durability. It’s not built to withstand wear and tear, high temperatures, or multiple washes and that matters when it comes to both your health and the environment.

Why Your Bottle May Be a Bacterial Hotbed

The grooves and crannies in thin plastic bottles create the perfect breeding ground for bacteria, especially after they’ve been used for 24 to 48 hours. According to Philip Tierno, PhD, clinical professor of microbiology and pathology at NYU Langone, biofilms slimy layers of bacteria can form inside bottles, similar to plaque on your teeth.

A 2018 study in the Journal of Exercise Physiology found that 90% of reused disposable bottles tested from gym-goers were contaminated with pathogens, including E. coli, which can indicate fecal contamination and bring a risk of illnesses like norovirus or salmonella.

Cleaning Isn’t Always Enough

Even if you’re diligent about washing your bottle, the thin, porous nature of single-use plastics makes it difficult to fully sanitize. During COVID-19, the risk became even greater. Surfaces can carry traces of viruses and bacteria from hands, public tables, or gym bags.

Tierno advises against using disposable plastic bottles for more than 24 hours and certainly no longer than 48. “You can refill the bottle as often as you like for 24 hours, but then discard it,” he says.

Chemical Leaching Is a Real Concern

Beyond bacteria, there’s another risk to reusing plastic: chemicals seeping into your water. While most PET bottles are considered safe for a single use, damage from scratches, heat, or UV exposure can cause compounds like acetaldehyde and antimony trioxide to leach into the liquid.

In a 2019 study from Environmental Science & Technology, researchers noted that high temperatures and sunlight significantly increased chemical release from PET bottles. And while these chemicals may be present in trace amounts, repeated exposure could contribute to hormonal disruption or other health effects over time.

Reusable bottles made of stainless steel or glass don’t carry the same risk, as their non-porous surfaces are much easier to clean and more stable under heat.

It’s Also Tough on the Planet

While reusing a plastic bottle might seem eco-friendly, it’s actually a small patch on a bigger problem. In 2018 alone, the U.S. generated 27 million tons of plastic waste, with only 29% of PET and HDPE bottles being recycled, according to the EPA.

The production and disposal of these bottles generate greenhouse gases, pollute oceans, and introduce toxic chemicals into soil and water systems. A 2019 study in the Journal of Toxicology and Risk Assessment noted that burning plastic can release dangerous compounds into the air, while ocean plastic continues to harm marine ecosystems worldwide.

What to Do Instead

You don’t need to give up bottled water completely, but switching to a safer, reusable option is a small change that pays off for both your health and the planet. Here are a few simple alternatives:

• Invest in a reusable water bottle. Stainless steel and glass are durable, non-toxic, and easy to clean.

• Use a home water filter. If taste or safety is a concern, filtered tap water can be a great solution.

• Recycle responsibly. If you must use single-use plastic, make sure it ends up in the recycling bin not the landfill.

So, How Bad Is It Really to Reuse a Disposable Plastic Water Bottle?

In normal times, refilling a disposable bottle for a day or two might not cause immediate harm. But doing it regularly increases your risk of exposure to bacteria and chemicals and it’s not great for the environment, either. If you're looking for the safest and most sustainable option, reusable bottles are the clear winner.

If this article helped you rethink your plastic use, share it or subscribe to our newsletter for more healthy living tips.