Not automatically. Cleveland Clinic says there is no clear sign that avoiding nightshade vegetables will make arthritis pain go away.
The nightshade family includes tomatoes, white potatoes, eggplant and peppers. Many people swear a few bites raise joint swelling and stiffness, and Cleveland Clinic says that debate has raged for decades. The worry centers on solanine, a compound in these plants, but the clinic says the low levels in edible nightshades make them safe to eat. One warning: throw away potatoes that have turned green, since that color may signal unhealthy levels of solanine.
On arthritis itself, the research is limited and conflicting, the clinic says. Some evidence suggests solanine can irritate the gut and cause inflammation, and a 2020 study on an anti-inflammatory diet for people with arthritis advised against tomatoes, potatoes and eggplant. Yet other research suggests purple potatoes, also a nightshade, may reduce inflammation. Rheumatologist Leonard Calabrese, DO, says it would be a shame to drop such nutritious foods on an unfounded theory. "It is highly unlikely that avoiding the trace amounts of solanine found in nightshade vegetables will ease your arthritic pain or inflammation," he says.
The Arthritis Foundation agrees. It says most reports are anecdotal, and no scientific studies prove nightshades cause inflammation or make symptoms worse. It calls them a worthy addition to your diet, and red peppers even appear on its list of best vegetables for arthritis. If you suspect a particular food bothers your joints, raise it with your doctor rather than cutting out a whole group of vegetables on your own.
What does help? Dr. Calabrese says one of the best ways to reduce arthritis symptoms is simply to eat well: an anti-inflammatory pattern such as the Mediterranean diet, mostly plants, with fruits, vegetables, legumes, whole grains, nuts and healthy fats, while limiting processed meats, fried foods and refined carbohydrates.
The nightshade name covers a huge plant family called Solanaceae, with more than 2,000 members, Cleveland Clinic says. The pepper group alone runs from green, red, orange and yellow bell peppers to chili peppers such as habaneros, jalapenos and cayenne. Plants make solanine to repel hungry insects and animals, and some nightshade plants are unsafe to eat, one of them named deadly nightshade. That history helps explain the worry, even though the clinic says edible nightshades carry only low levels. The clinic adds that a green potato risks a nasty bout of nausea or diarrhea, which is why it says to throw those away.
The Arthritis Foundation explains why red peppers made its best-vegetables list. Peppers of any color, mild or hot, are a rich source of vitamin C, which preserves bone and may protect cartilage cells, and the foundation says a half-cup of red bell pepper gives you a full day's supply. Red peppers also carry plant pigments called carotenoids, and the foundation says some research suggests eating more foods rich in one of them, beta-cryptoxanthin, could reduce the risk of developing rheumatoid arthritis. Kim Larson, a Seattle-based dietitian and Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics spokesperson quoted by the foundation, says nightshades might well bother some people even without studies to prove it, which is a good reason to raise a suspected trigger with your doctor.
Beyond diet, Cleveland Clinic notes that exercise can improve arthritis symptoms, with low-impact exercise best. The Arthritis Foundation says losing weight eases pain and improves how well medicine works in people with arthritis. It also says the more color on your plate the better, and variety is key, since vegetables carry antioxidants that lower inflammation throughout the body, including in the joints.
This is general information, not medical advice: talk to your doctor if you keep noticing joint pain after particular foods.
