The Difference Between Soup and Stew Explained

As temperatures drop and cozy cooking takes center stage, soup and stew become staples in kitchens everywhere. But what separates these two comforting dishes? While they share similarities both are hearty, warming, and endlessly customizable their differences lie in preparation, consistency, and composition. Here’s a closer look to help you master your next culinary creation.

What Is Soup?

Soup is defined by its liquid-forward nature, with broth or stock serving as the main base. Typically, ingredients like meat, vegetables, or grains are simmered together, creating a dish that’s flavorful, light, and easy to sip or spoon.

The process starts with the liquid: whether you’re making homemade stock from bones and vegetable scraps or using store-bought broth, this forms the foundation. Ingredients like aromatics, proteins, and starches are then added to cook through and infuse the liquid.

Examples include:

• Chicken noodle soup: A comfort food classic with savory broth, tender chicken, and noodles.

• Tomato soup: Silky and rich, often paired with a gooey grilled cheese.

• Miso soup: A light, umami-packed favorite featuring miso paste and tofu.

What Is Stew?

Stew flips the script by making the solid ingredients the stars. Chunks of meat, vegetables, or legumes are cooked first, with just enough liquid (broth, stock, or water) added to tenderize and enhance the flavors. The result? A thicker, gravy-like consistency that’s heartier than soup.

Key stews include:

• Chili: Packed with beans, tomatoes, and spices, this dish is a game-day essential.

• Gumbo: A Southern classic, rich with seafood or sausage and often served over rice.

• Coq au vin: A French favorite of chicken braised in wine, mushrooms, and herbs.

The primary distinction? Liquid ratio. Soup is more liquid-heavy, while stew has just enough to cook and coat the ingredients.

What About Chowder?

Enter chowder: a cream-based soup that’s thicker than traditional soups but less chunky than stews. Often seafood-centric (like clam chowder), it’s hearty and rich. Crackers are sometimes crushed into the dish to absorb liquid and thicken it further.

Though its origins trace back to French fishermen, chowder has become synonymous with New England, where creamy clam chowder reigns supreme.

Best Practices for Soup and Stew Success

• Start with flavor: Use broth or stock over water to enhance the taste from the start.

• Build in layers: Add spices and aromatics gradually to deepen the flavors.

• Use a big pot: More ingredients mean better results, so don’t be shy with portions.

• Experiment with consistency: Let soup simmer longer for a thicker, stew-like finish.

Whether you’re making a light soup or a hearty stew, both are perfect for the season. So grab your biggest pot, choose your ingredients, and let the magic simmer away.

For more flavorful recipes and cooking tips, subscribe to our newsletter.