How to Know When a Three-Way Friendship Has Turned Toxic

Not all friendships are built to last and some can start to take a serious toll on your emotional wellbeing, especially in small, tight-knit groups of three. While having two besties sounds ideal in theory (hello, constant group texts, built-in travel buddies, and shared memories), the dynamic can also come with its own share of unspoken competition, exclusion, and emotional imbalance.

When you find yourself stuck in a trio where one person frequently plays the role of peacekeeper, scapegoat, or third wheel, it’s worth asking Is this friendship still healthy for me?

What a healthy friendship should feel like

According to experts, healthy friendships are grounded in mutual respect, trust, and open communication. You should feel comfortable being your full self, supported in your highs and lows, and genuinely uplifted by your friend group. “In a balanced trio, each person feels seen and valued,” says neuropsychologist Sanam Hafeez, PsyD.

But in a toxic three-way friendship, things can quickly spiral into drama, manipulation, or even emotional harm often without anyone realizing what’s happening until the damage is done.

Signs your three-way friendship might be toxic

Here’s what to look out for:

• You're always the mediator. If you’re constantly stuck smoothing over tension between the other two, you may be carrying the emotional weight of the group.

• Someone is always left out. Whether it's you or someone else, consistent exclusion is a major red flag.

• There’s underlying competition. Toxic dynamics can show up as subtle one-upping, jealousy, or backhanded compliments especially around romantic interests or success.

• You feel anxious before seeing them. Dread, stress, or overthinking interactions is a sign that something’s off.

• You’re not being heard. If your voice feels dismissed or overlooked in conversations, you may be in an imbalanced dynamic.

• The friendship is no longer energizing. You leave hangouts feeling drained, insecure, or emotionally bruised this should never be the norm.

And if you’ve noticed yourself changing just to fit in, over-giving to maintain peace, or tolerating behavior that crosses your boundaries, those are signs the relationship may be taking more from you than it gives.

The impact of staying in a toxic trio

Being stuck in a tense friend group isn’t just emotionally exhausting it can affect your self-esteem, mental health, and even your physical wellbeing. Constant stress from toxic friendships can trigger anxiety, disrupt sleep, and impact how you view yourself in all relationships.

“When someone consistently makes you feel less than or unsafe emotionally, it starts to rewire how you think about connection and trust,” says therapist Kristin Wilson, LPC.

Why toxic friendships happen especially in threes

Oftentimes, toxic dynamics in three-person groups come from insecurity, unresolved trauma, or learned behaviors. Someone who didn’t grow up with healthy relationship models may unconsciously mirror manipulative or controlling patterns. Others may act out of fear fearing abandonment, rejection, or not being enough.

In a trio, it’s easy for alliances to shift and power imbalances to form. The group dynamic might feel fun and light one week, then uncomfortable and tense the next. That emotional whiplash can keep you stuck, hoping for the good times to return.

What to do if you think your friendship is toxic

Start with self-reflection. Ask yourself:

• How do I feel after spending time with this group?

• Do I trust them to support me during difficult times?

• Do I feel safe and seen in this friendship or small and unsure?

Try having a conversation. If it feels safe to do so, open up to your friends about how you’ve been feeling. Use “I” statements to express your emotions without placing blame, and suggest new boundaries that help protect your peace. For example, maybe you propose more one-on-one time or take a break from group hangouts.

Give yourself permission to take space. Sometimes the most powerful thing you can do is step back and observe how your life feels without the constant drama or emotional tension. You don’t owe anyone your presence especially not at the cost of your mental health.

Know when to walk away. If your concerns are dismissed, if the behavior doesn’t change, or if the friendship continues to leave you feeling worse it’s okay to let go. Ending a friendship, especially one you’ve invested time and heart into, can be incredibly hard. But it also makes room for new connections rooted in care, respect, and real joy.

You deserve better

If a friendship no matter how fun or nostalgic leaves you doubting your worth, walking on eggshells, or questioning your identity, it may be time to move on. The end of one relationship is never the end of your story. And often, choosing yourself is the most loving thing you can do.

If this article resonated with you, please consider sharing it or subscribing to our newsletter for more stories on emotional wellbeing.