Why Breathing Into a Paper Bag Isn’t the Best Way to Treat Hyperventilation

We’ve all seen the scene: someone starts to panic, their breathing becomes rapid and shallow, and a well-meaning friend hands them a brown paper bag to breathe into. While this method is iconic in pop culture, breathing into a paper bag isn’t always safe or effective and in some cases, it can make the situation worse.

What Happens During Hyperventilation?

Hyperventilation often triggered by panic attacks or extreme anxiety is when you breathe too quickly or deeply, causing a drop in carbon dioxide (CO₂) levels in your blood. This imbalance can lead to symptoms like:

• Lightheadedness or dizziness

• Chest tightness

• Tingling in the hands or feet

• Shortness of breath

The theory behind the paper bag method is simple: rebreathing your exhaled air may help restore CO₂ levels to normal. But this isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution and it may be dangerous in the wrong context.

Why the Paper Bag Method Isn't Always Safe

While the idea behind it may sound reasonable, there’s little scientific evidence that breathing into a paper bag is a reliable or safe treatment for hyperventilation. More importantly, misusing this method can delay proper medical care when something more serious is going on.

Several critical health conditions can mimic the symptoms of hyperventilation, including:

• Heart attacks

• Asthma or COPD (chronic obstructive pulmonary disease)

• Head injuries

• Diabetic ketoacidosis

• High-altitude sickness

In these situations, reducing oxygen intake by breathing into a paper bag could be harmful or even life-threatening. For example, during a heart attack, your body needs more oxygen not less.

A Safer Alternative: Breathing Exercises That Actually Work

Instead of using a paper bag, experts recommend calming breathing techniques to gently slow the breath and reduce anxiety. Try this simple method:

1. Sit down in a comfortable position.

2. Inhale slowly through your nose for a count of four.

3. Hold your breath for a count of four.

4. Exhale gently through your mouth for a count of six.

5. Repeat for several minutes until your breathing returns to normal.

In a 2016 study from Brunel University in the UK, participants with hyperventilation syndrome who practiced breathing exercises experienced a significant reduction in the frequency and severity of attacks. These exercises are low-risk and highly effective, especially when combined with long-term anxiety management.

Managing Chronic Hyperventilation

If you experience frequent episodes of hyperventilation, it may be linked to panic disorder, generalized anxiety, or other mental health conditions. The best long-term approach focuses on treating the root cause. Options include:

• Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT)

• Anti-anxiety medications, as prescribed by a healthcare provider

• Mindfulness practices and stress reduction techniques

• Regular physical activity

For those living with chronic anxiety or panic attacks, working with a mental health professional can be life-changing.

When to Skip the Paper Bag and Call for Help

While hyperventilation is often benign, some symptoms are red flags that should never be ignored. Seek immediate medical care if you experience:

• Chest pain

• Bluish lips, fingers, or skin

• Fainting or extreme dizziness

• Confusion or difficulty speaking

• Persistent fever

These symptoms may signal a more serious condition, and using the paper bag method could delay critical care.

Bottom Line: Know the Difference and When to Get Help

The paper bag technique may seem harmless, but in the wrong circumstances, it can be risky. For occasional anxiety-induced hyperventilation, controlled breathing exercises and calm surroundings are safer and more effective. But if you’re unsure about the cause or if the episode is severe or new it’s always best to consult a healthcare provider.

If this article helped you or someone you know, please share it or subscribe to our newsletter for more health tips and insights.